Friday, January 18, 2008

The curse of Calderdale???

In recent days, recording areas directly neighbouring ours have turned up some great birds, despite it being January. Granted, both of their areas are bigger and you could argue more diverse in habitat, but in the past week alone...
Bradford - glaucous gull, scaup, red crested pochard, little egret, black-necked grebe, white-fronted goose
East Lancs - slavonian grebe, great grey shrike, caspian gull, glaucous gull, scaup, red-breasted merganser, pintail.

In the same period, we appear to have had relatively little. These are nearly all birds that have in the mists of time appeared in Calderdale on more than one occassion, so what is happening? Are they making a huge detour to go round us these days? Or are they there and we're just not picking them up?

Alright, it's not exactly the Carmargue round here, but I think there is a danger that we are missing birds that are out there, and therefore people think that Calderdale isn't worth birding in and go out of area, so we miss birds that are out there..........etc in circles.

7 comments:

David Sutcliffe said...

It's always been like that in Calderdale Matt (well since 1970 anyway)!!! We have our rewards - but it's hard work.

Alf King said...

It's not just Calderdale. Kirklees (well the Huddersfield part) has been a bit bereft of any birds of note of late.

Still it makes the special birds even that bit more special when we find them.

Goldon Gordon said...

I had a conversation with Andy C about this some weeks back. Calderdale is a "black hole" for migrant moths and whilst I do bag the occasional migrant moth its only when there is a huge influx elsewhere. As we are right in the "Calder Gap" from Lancashire its always been a mystery to me why we don't seem to get migrants moving through this gap in the Pennines ? Andy at the time seemed to suggest that it was very similar with migrant birds. The South Pennines has quite an impoverished flora and fauna compared to many areas and thus perhaps its not worth hanging around if you are migrant ! Historically from what I can see we seem never to have anything that special flora or fauna wise ?

Echoing other comments, at least when we do get something out of the ordinary here in Calderdale we have the pleasure of knowing its been earned and thus more special.

Nick Dawtrey said...

re- bradford sightings. Spoke to Tony Gough last night and he told me the Glaucous Gull was un viewable the Scaup was so distant that you could barely make it out and the Red-crested Pochard was a probable escape.

darrell j prest said...

seen all of them in calderdale apart from black necked grebe,red crested pochard(still awaiting caspian gull decision,though i hold little hope ) despite what i may say on my own blog.
calderdale is not that bad,
the area is vastly underwatched because many places are too remote for a 'casual visit'which is why ringstone seems to get all the good stuff,just pull up and a quick check over the res.
the rochdale guys have whiteholme covered and walshaw by the burnley lot.
we have the sites but not the coverage.
just imagine what dave sutcliffe,brian sumner,nick dawtrey etc would find if they did whiteholme everyday.

Matt Bell said...

Incidentally, there's been no report of the GG shrike from East Lancs for a couple of days.

Nick Carter said...

Back there today Matt